Share This Article
Article Summary
Cincinnati plans to hire an outside consultant to organize City Manager Sheryl Long’s annual performance review. The expected $148,600 cost will come from the City Manager’s Office discretionary fund, and City Council will retain final evaluation authority. Council also expects an explanation of rising rape and strangulation reports at a Dec. 1 meeting.
Cincinnati plans to hire a third-party consultant to manage City Manager Sheryl Long’s annual performance review.
This is shifting this year’s process from a Council-led evaluation to one coordinated by Mayor Aftab Pureval’s office.
Council member Scotty Johnson announced the plan Nov. 17 during the Public Safety and Quality of Life Committee. The city has requested proposals and evaluated bids from multiple applicants, according to WVXU’s report.
The city expects to name the selected firm within a few weeks.
Consultant will organize the review process
The consultant’s role will include gathering performance information, collecting confidential feedback, helping Council discuss its evaluation and recommending improvements to future reviews. The request for proposals describes a full annual cycle, including goal setting, performance measurement and development planning.
Council will remain the sole evaluating authority. The consultant is expected to facilitate the process and provide structure, while Council retains responsibility for evaluating the city manager.
The expected cost is $148,600, paid from the City Manager’s Office discretionary fund. WVXU reported the expense does not require City Council approval. Council member Mark Jeffreys, who has led past reviews, said an outside facilitator could broaden input from employees, residents and city data.
Crime figures add a second issue for Council
Long’s annual report also presented a mixed picture of public safety. It highlighted declines in shootings, homicides and robberies, alongside increases in reported rapes and strangulations. The figures in Long’s presentation showed rape reports up 55 percent and strangulation reports up 40% compared with the same period last year, WVXU reported.
A separate Cincinnati Police Department STARS report published Nov. 2 counted 263 rape reports through Oct. 31, compared with 167 during the same period in 2025. It recorded 352 strangulation reports, up from 247. The department labels STARS figures preliminary and subject to revision.
The city has said that changes in state law and reporting practices contributed to the increases. However, reported cases do not necessarily correspond to offenses that took place in the same calendar year. A Cincinnati Exchange review of police records found that about one-third of the added rape reports through October involved offenses from earlier years.
Seven Council members requested a presentation explaining the crime data. The committee held that motion on Nov. 17, and the administration is expected to report back Dec. 1, according to the official Council record. A separate motion proposes a coordinated response to suspected strangulation cases involving hospitals, police, emergency services and victim-support organizations.
Selection expected in few weeks
The consultant selection is expected within a few weeks. Council’s Dec. 1 discussion should provide more detail on the crime-reporting increases and how much may reflect data corrections or changes in classification.
FAQs
Do the crime figures show when offenses occurred?
Not necessarily. Some reports logged in 2026 involve offenses from earlier years, so report totals should not be treated as a direct count of offenses that happened during 2026.
Will residents be able to read the review results?
The RFP calls for reporting findings, but the city has not yet explained which parts of the process or final results will be public. The city is expected to provide more details after selecting a firm.
Will the consultant decide whether Long keeps her job?
No. The consultant will facilitate the review and report findings. City Council remains the sole evaluating authority.
Can Cincinnati residents provide feedback to the consultant?
The RFP includes confidential feedback collection, but the city has not yet announced whether or how residents can submit feedback. Residents can watch for details when the city names the consultant and explains the review process.



