Share This Article
Liberty Township is preparing for a public hearing next month that could shape the future of short-term rentals in the community.
The case involves a homeowner appealing a zoning decision related to the operation of a short-term rental (STR) inside a single-family neighborhood — a dispute that mirrors a much broader national debate about whether Airbnb-style rentals belong in residential areas at all.
The hearing, scheduled for December 9 at 6:00 p.m. at the Liberty Township Administration Building (5021 Winners Circle Drive), gives local residents a rare chance to weigh in directly on how the township should handle short-term rentals (STRs) moving forward.
A Local Flashpoint in a National Issue
While this appeal focuses on a single property, the underlying issue is familiar across the country: STRs are increasingly operating inside quiet cul-de-sacs and family-oriented subdivisions. What began as a way for travelers to stay in urban lofts or resort towns has quickly migrated into suburban neighborhoods never designed for transient lodging.
Liberty Township officials have already taken steps to manage the situation. Earlier this year, township leaders implemented a moratorium on STRs, followed by a clear declaration that such uses are not permitted in single-family zones. The township cited concerns about neighborhood stability, enforcement challenges, and the impact that high turnover rentals can have on residents.
Ohio State law gives townships the power to regulate land use, including banning or restricting short-term rentals. And Liberty Township’s zoning rules and procedures are clear.
Now, with the latest zoning appeal, the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) will evaluate whether the zoning inspector correctly applied the rules — effectively making this one of the first major tests of Liberty Township’s STR policy.
Why Residents Are Concerned
The debate over STRs in residential neighborhoods isn’t abstract. Across the region, suburban homeowners are raising similar concerns:
Constant Turnover of Guests
One of the biggest concerns homeowners raise about short-term rentals is the steady flow of strangers cycling in and out of residential streets. Suburban neighborhoods rely heavily on familiarity — knowing who lives next door, recognizing the cars in the driveway, and feeling comfortable when children play outside. But when a home becomes a rotating lodging operation, that sense of stability disappears.
Families may notice new vehicles parked out front every few days, different faces entering the property each weekend, or late-night groups pulling luggage across the driveway long after the rest of the block has gone to sleep. Even if the guests are well-intentioned, the sheer volume of unfamiliar people can make longtime residents uneasy. It’s harder to distinguish between a normal visitor and someone who shouldn’t be there, and parents often express discomfort at the idea of their kids riding bikes or playing basketball with a constant flow of unknown adults nearby.
Neighborhood trust is something built over years — but it can evaporate almost instantly when turnover becomes the norm.
Noise, Parking, and Disruptions
Short-term rentals may advertise themselves as “quiet retreats,” but the reality is that high-turnover lodging brings a different rhythm than owner-occupied homes. Travelers often operate on vacation time or business-trip schedules that don’t match the routines of the families living around them.
We’ve dealt with loud parties, cars flooding the street, and even guests letting their dog defecate in our yard. This is a quiet neighborhood, and the constant disruptions from these short-term rentals make it feel like we’re living next to a hotel instead of a home.
– Paul Dittman, resident
This can mean:
-
Late-night or early-morning check-ins when guests arrive from the airport or long drives
-
Large groups staying together, which naturally leads to more noise, more vehicles, and more foot traffic
-
Extra cars spilling into the street, blocking sidewalks or crowding areas where children typically play
-
Overflowing trash bins after weekend stays or short trips from multiple separate groups
-
Outdoor activity and lights left on late into the night, because guests don’t always observe the same courtesies as neighbors
In cul-de-sacs, where sound echoes and homes sit close together, these disruptions are amplified. A single weekend rental can feel like a small event venue — and when it happens repeatedly, it strains the patience of even the most tolerant residents.
Loss of Neighborhood Character
Suburban communities don’t just consist of houses — they’re made up of relationships. Neighbors look out for one another, share seasonal traditions, talk across driveways, and invest years into building a cohesive, safe environment.
When a house becomes a short-term rental, that continuity breaks. Instead of stable neighbors you know and trust, the home becomes a revolving mini-hotel. Porch lights stay on at odd hours, blinds remain drawn, and the personal touches that anchor a home — kids’ bikes, seasonal decorations, a familiar dog on the porch — give way to a generic, transient feel.
Over time, a block with multiple STRs can lose the very features that attracted families in the first place. Some residents describe it as living next to a “ghost house” that’s constantly occupied but never really part of the community. That erosion of identity affects everything from neighborhood cohesion to property values.
Subdivisions are designed to foster a predictable, stable environment. When one home becomes a short-term rental, it shifts the character of the street — and when several do, the entire neighborhood can change in ways residents never agreed to.
Impact on Property Values
Homeowners often worry that the presence of short-term rentals can make their properties less desirable — and in many cases, real estate professionals agree. When a home on the block is used as a high-turnover lodging business, it changes how potential buyers perceive the neighborhood. For families looking for stability, privacy, and a predictable environment, the prospect of an Airbnb next door is a major red flag.
Buyers may ask:
-
“Who are all these people coming and going?”
-
“Will our kids be safe playing outside?”
-
“Will parking be a headache?”
-
“Will this hurt resale value down the road?”
Even if nothing “bad” happens, the uncertainty alone can shrink the buyer pool. Fewer interested buyers can translate directly into lower sale prices for surrounding homes.
Real estate agents frequently note that homes adjacent to or near short-term rentals often take longer to sell — and when they do sell, it’s sometimes at a discount compared to identical homes in similar neighborhoods without STR activity. Lenders and insurers have also begun flagging properties near STR clusters due to higher risk profiles.
For many families, their home is their largest financial investment. When one property on the street becomes a vacation rental, it introduces a layer of instability that homeowners didn’t sign up for — and may directly affect the equity they’ve spent years building.
Why Property Owners Push Back on Short-term Rentals
Not all STR hosts see themselves as running an Airbnb hotel. Many frame their rentals as:
-
Temporary corporate housing
-
A furnished home for families between moves
-
A flexible month-to-month option for traveling workers
Some homeowners also believe the government is overreaching by limiting how people can use their property. Others argue they began operating before restrictions existed and should be allowed to continue under “grandfathered” status.
This tension — between community stability and individual property rights — is the core of the appeal the BZA will hear.
Why This Short-term Rentals Hearing Matters
The December 9 hearing is more than a procedural meeting. It is the community’s opportunity to speak directly to the board deciding how STRs fit — or don’t fit — within Liberty Township.
Residents who care about the direction of their neighborhoods should strongly consider attending. Public testimony can influence the board’s understanding of:
-
How STRs affect local streets
-
What residents are experiencing on the ground
-
Whether short-term rentals align with the township’s vision for its future
This is one of the few moments where everyday citizens have a clear, official forum to share their perspective.
A Call to the Community
Whether you support property owners’ flexibility or believe STRs threaten neighborhood stability, your voice matters. Liberty Township is actively shaping its policies right now, and public input will help determine what kind of community it becomes in the years ahead.
Residents are encouraged to attend the public hearing on short-term rentals:
Tuesday, December 9
6:00 PM (or shortly after)
Liberty Township Administration Building
Local government only works when the people it serves show up. This hearing is an opportunity for residents to make their views heard — and to help set the course for Liberty Township’s future.
Read More
Law-enforcement officials report gains in coordinated effort to tackle downtown Cincinnati crime
Lead Pipe Scandal in Cincinnati Exposes Systemic Oversight Failures
