Share This Article
On a pleasant November night built for a statement win, FC Cincinnati delivered the opposite.
What unfolded at TQL Stadium was not just a defeat — it was a collapse, a tactical unraveling that ended the club’s playoff run in a 4–0 rout at the hands of Inter Miami.
For a team defined by home-field dominance, intensity, and resilience, this FC Cincinnati loss was one of the most jarring in recent memory.
This wasn’t a bad night — it was a seismic failure on the biggest stage. Our very own health and fitness writer, Josh Smith was there for the action and said:
Messi scored the first goal off a perfect pass, and that took every FC Cincinnati player’s soul. It was over after that.
The Stakes Were High. Miami Played Like It. Cincinnati Didn’t.
From the opening whistle, Miami approached the match with playoff ruthlessness. The early tone-setting moment came in the 19th minute, when Lionel Messi slipped into the box unmarked and headed home a cross from Mateo Silvetti.
That goal didn’t just put Miami ahead — it shattered Cincinnati’s early rhythm and exposed defensive hesitation that would only worsen as the match unfolded.
Second Half: The Floodgates Opened
The second half wasn’t competitive. It was clinical punishment.
- 57’ — 2–0: Silvetti finished a Messi-assisted attack that carved through the midfield.
- 62’ — 3–0: Tadeo Allende scored off a fast break, again fed by Messi.
- 74’ — 4–0: Allende struck again from the center of the box, completing the rout.
Every Miami chance felt dangerous. Every FCC reaction felt slow. And every Messi touch felt like a warning Cincinnati couldn’t handle.
Head-to-Head History Makes This Loss Even More Stunning
What makes this FC Cincinnati loss sting even worse is the recent dominance FCC showed in the matchup. Coming into this playoff clash, Cincinnati had won three of the previous five meetings, including a 6–1 win and a 3–0 shutout earlier this season.
| Match | Score | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Inter Miami CF vs FC Cincinnati | 0–0 | Jul 26, 2025 |
| FC Cincinnati vs Inter Miami CF | 3–0 | Jul 16, 2025 |
| Inter Miami CF vs FC Cincinnati | 2–0 | Aug 24, 2024 |
| FC Cincinnati vs Inter Miami CF | 6–1 | Jul 6, 2024 |
| Inter Miami CF vs FC Cincinnati | 0–1 | Oct 7, 2023 |
Given that history, losing 4–0 — at TQL Stadium — wasn’t just unexpected. It was shocking.
Match Statistics Tell a Painful Story in the FC Cincinnati loss
The final scoreline was one-sided, but the underlying numbers show a more frustrating truth: Cincinnati had enough of the ball and enough shots to be competitive, but lacked the quality and composure Miami displayed.
- Possession: FCC 49% — Miami 51%
- Shots on Goal: FCC 5 — Miami 6
- Shot Attempts: 14 — 14
- Corner Kicks: FCC 4 — Miami 2
- Saves: FCC 2 — Miami 5
Even possession. Equal shot attempts. More corners. And yet: 4–0. Miami simply executed at an elite level, while Cincinnati wilted in the moments that decide playoff games.
This Was a Mental Collapse More Than a Tactical One
Tactically, Cincinnati was second best — but mentally, they were miles off the pace. Once Miami’s second goal went in, FCC’s resolve evaporated. Body language dipped, defensive rotations slowed, and urgency turned into panic.
You can’t survive knockout matches like that. Miami stayed composed. Cincinnati fell apart.
Cincinnati Must Rebuild Its Defensive Core
The back line looked overwhelmed. Miami repeatedly found space between the lines, and FCC’s defensive shape broke down on every major Miami chance. This offseason is now defined by one question:
Can this defensive unit win in the postseason? Based on tonight, the answer is no.
Coaching Adjustments Came Too Late in the FC Cincinnati loss
Pat Noonan has elevated this club, but he was outcoached in this match. Miami anticipated Cincinnati’s press. FCC never effectively countered Miami’s midfield overloads or transition patterns.
When Miami made their tactical push, Cincinnati had no Plan B — a fatal flaw at this stage of the season.
A Brutal Night, but a Clear Blueprint for Growth
This FC Cincinnati loss wasn’t just a defeat — it was a wake-up call. The talent is real. The trajectory is positive. But the gap between a good MLS club and a championship contender is built on composure, defensive solidity, and tactical adaptability.
Cincinnati now enters a pivotal offseason where those weaknesses must be addressed.
Read More
FC Cincinnati: Built to Win — The Push for Playoff Glory in 2025
Bengals vs. Patriots: Record Kick, Late Drama, Same Painful Result for Cincinnati
